---
title: Startup insurance brokers compared: model, pay and servicing | by Delegance
description: Broker, MGA or practice of a larger firm: how five startup insurance brokers describe themselves, how they are paid and how they work, each fact sourced and dated. Published by Delegance.
---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it.

# Startup insurance brokers compared

The brokers founders hear about are built differently. Some write their own programs, some joined larger firms, some charge a flat fee. Those choices decide who the broker answers to and what it earns. This page compares five on their own terms.

## What Delegance brings

- **What it is.** An independent commercial insurance brokerage. Delegance places coverage with insurance companies and does not underwrite the risk itself. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/vs-traditional-broker))
- **How the broker is paid.** A flat, disclosed 5% fee in place of the 15 to 25% commission a traditional broker typically takes. You see the rate before you buy. (stated by Delegance)
- **Speed to quote and bind.** Free quotes with no signup through the portal, the CLI or the MCP server; instant online quotes for eligible classes; multi-carrier quotes typically within 24 hours. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/how-it-works))
- **D&O, E&O, cyber and EPL.** Places directors and officers (D&O), professional liability (E&O), cyber and employment practices liability (EPLI), with general liability, workers comp and the rest of a company's commercial program. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/llms.txt))
- **Cost or savings statement.** Total insurance expense typically falls 10 to 20% on a placement, with the same admitted carriers. Your result depends on your risk, your carriers and your current program. (stated by Delegance)
- **Carriers and reach.** Appointed directly by 25 carriers, including Chubb, Travelers and The Hartford. (stated by Delegance)
- **Licensing.** Licensed in 51 jurisdictions (all 50 states and DC), agency NPN 21282686. (stated by Delegance)

[Get a free Delegance quote](https://portal.delegancebrokerage.com/onboarding/company?ref=startupinsurancebrokers.com&utm_source=comparison_site&utm_medium=web&utm_content=home_brief) Delegance publishes this page and earns a flat, disclosed fee if you buy through it.

## Side by side

Each entry for another firm is that firm's own statement, with the source and the date we read it. Delegance entries are Delegance's own statements.

| Criterion | Delegance | Vouch (Insurance for Technology Companies) | Embroker (Embroker Management Insurance Suite (EMIS)) | Founder Shield (The Baldwin Group Innovation Practice (formerly Founder Shield)) | Newfront (Executive Risk Solutions) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| What it is | An independent commercial insurance brokerage. Delegance places coverage with insurance companies and does not underwrite the risk itself. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/vs-traditional-broker)) | Calls itself "a broker, not an insurance carrier," with products brokered through Vouch Specialty Insurance Services, LLC. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/llms.txt), read Nov 17, 2026) | You designate Embroker as your broker of record or agent of record under its terms; it says it may also provide underwriting services for some insurer partners. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/terms/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Describes itself as a licensed independent insurance broker; its homepage now reads, 'Founder Shield is now the Innovation Practice of The Baldwin Group.' ([source](https://foundershield.com/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Describes itself as a brokerage now operating as part of WTW. Its own site headlines the deal 'WTW Completes Acquisition of Newfront,' dated January 27, 2026. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/news/newfront-next-chapter-joining-wtw), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| How the broker is paid | A flat, disclosed 5% fee in place of the 15 to 25% commission a traditional broker typically takes. You see the rate before you buy. (stated by Delegance) | Its disclosures say it earns commission from appointed carriers and may also be paid on the performance of products sold. No percentage found on its disclosures, licenses, home, technology or cost-guide pages. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/legal/disclosures), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its disclosure lists usual and customary commissions or fees, contingent commissions, supplemental commissions and client fees as its pay types. No percentage found on its disclosure, terms or licenses pages. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/disclosure/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its terms list a retail commission (a percentage of premium), a separate client fee, and contingent commissions as its pay types. No percentage found on its terms, startup insurance or coverage pages. ([source](https://foundershield.com/terms-of-service/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its Total Rewards (employee benefits) terms list Standard Commissions paid by insurance carriers and Supplemental Commissions tied to volume or retention as its pay types. No percentage found on its terms or total rewards pages; no separate P&C compensation disclosure found. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/terms/total-rewards), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Speed to quote and bind | Free quotes with no signup through the portal, the CLI or the MCP server; instant online quotes for eligible classes; multi-carrier quotes typically within 24 hours. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/how-it-works)) | States 81% same-day quoting on its homepage. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says EMIS applicants may get an underwriting response in the same session, "replacing a process that has traditionally taken days or weeks." Its cyber page separately says a quote in under 10 minutes. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/blog/embroker-launches-emis), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says a startup can submit an application in under 15 minutes and get a quote and coverage in minutes. ([source](https://foundershield.com/startup-insurance/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says its technology practice runs automated contract reviews in seconds instead of hours or days with generative AI. No quote-in-minutes or same-day bind claim found on its executive risk, technology or venture capital pages. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/technology), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| D&O, E&O, cyber and EPL | Places directors and officers (D&O), professional liability (E&O), cyber and employment practices liability (EPLI), with general liability, workers comp and the rest of a company's commercial program. ([source](https://www.delegancebrokerage.com/llms.txt)) | Its technology practice page lists Tech Errors & Omissions, Cyber Liability, Directors & Officers (D&O), General Liability and Employment Practices Liability (EPLI) among the coverages it places. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/technology), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its EMIS package brings Directors & Officers (D&O) liability, Employment Practices Liability (EPL), Fiduciary Liability and Technology Errors & Omissions/Cyber Liability into one application. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/blog/embroker-launches-emis), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its core-coverages list for startups names cyber liability, directors and officers, employment practices liability and errors and omissions among the lines it places. ([source](https://foundershield.com/startup-insurance/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its executive risk page lists Directors and Officers (D&O) for private and public companies, Errors and Omissions, and Employment Practices Liability Insurance (EPLI) among its coverages. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/executive-risk), read Nov 17, 2026) |
| Cost or savings statement | Total insurance expense typically falls 10 to 20% on a placement, with the same admitted carriers. Your result depends on your risk, your carriers and your current program. (stated by Delegance) | Its own cost guide puts D&O at a median annual premium of $6,300, with a typical range of $3,000 to $16,800, across more than 3,000 startups. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/blog/startup-insurance-costs), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its D&O cost table prices a company that has raised $0 to $10M at a $4,000 to $6,000 premium with $1M to $2M in limits; one that has raised $100M to $250M at $21,000 to $50,000 with $8M to $10M in limits. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/coverage/directors-officers-insurance/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Not stated on the pages checked. | Not stated on the pages checked. |
| Carriers and reach | Appointed directly by 25 carriers, including Chubb, Travelers and The Hartford. (stated by Delegance) | Not stated on the pages checked. | Not stated on the pages checked. | Not stated on the pages checked. | Not stated on the pages checked. |
| Licensing | Licensed in 51 jurisdictions (all 50 states and DC), agency NPN 21282686. (stated by Delegance) | Lists property and casualty, and surplus lines, licenses for all 50 states plus DC and territories under NPN 19926463, with California marked as its resident state. ([source](https://www.vouch.us/legal/licenses), read Nov 17, 2026) | Its licenses page lists a license number for every state plus DC. No NPN found on its disclosure, licenses or terms pages. ([source](https://www.embroker.com/licenses/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says its services apply only where it, its affiliates, partner insurers, brokers or agents and employees are licensed and permitted to sell them. No state list or state count published on its terms page. ([source](https://foundershield.com/terms-of-service/), read Nov 17, 2026) | Says Newfront Insurance Services is licensed to sell insurance products in all 50 states, DC and Puerto Rico. The linked per-state license-number list is hosted off-site and was not reachable. ([source](https://www.newfront.com/terms), read Nov 17, 2026) |

## Head-to-head pages

- [Delegance vs Vouch (Insurance for Technology Companies)](/vs/vouch)
- [Delegance vs Embroker (Embroker Management Insurance Suite (EMIS))](/vs/embroker)
- [Delegance vs Founder Shield (The Baldwin Group Innovation Practice (formerly Founder Shield))](/vs/founder-shield)
- [Delegance vs Newfront (Executive Risk Solutions)](/vs/newfront)

## Common questions

### What is the difference between a broker and an MGA?

A broker represents you and places coverage with insurance companies. A managing general agent (MGA) underwrites on behalf of an insurance company. Some firms do both; each firm's terms say which roles it plays.

### Does it matter if my broker was acquired?

It can change who owns the relationship, which systems you use and how the broker is paid. Ask who services your account after the deal and whether the pay model changed.

### Can I change brokers mid-policy?

Yes. A broker of record letter moves servicing to a new broker. The policy, the carrier and the premium stay the same until renewal.

### Who publishes this comparison?

Delegance Brokerage publishes it and is one of the brokers compared. Every statement about another broker links to that broker's page and shows the date we read it.

Read the [guide](/how-to-choose) or the [sources and method](/sources).

[Get a free Delegance quote](https://portal.delegancebrokerage.com/onboarding/company?ref=startupinsurancebrokers.com&utm_source=comparison_site&utm_medium=web&utm_content=home_end) Delegance publishes this page and earns a flat, disclosed fee if you buy through it.

---

Published by Delegance Brokerage, a licensed commercial insurance broker and one of the brokers compared here. Delegance earns a flat, disclosed fee when you buy through it. This site is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any other company named on it. Company names belong to their owners and appear in plain text only.

Every statement about another broker links to that broker's own page and shows the date we read it. See [sources and method](/sources). To correct a fact, write to [alex@delegancebrokerage.com](mailto:alex@delegancebrokerage.com).

Insurance is placed by Delegance LLC dba Delegance Brokerage, NPN 21282686, 234 10th Ave, New York, NY 10011. Nothing here is an offer of insurance; coverage is subject to underwriting and policy terms. Savings figures are typical results, not a promise.
